By Michele Dillon
It's been good documented that American Catholics are typically Catholics all alone phrases, or decide to stay Catholic whereas selectively embracing authentic Church doctrine. yet why do Catholics who disagree with professional Church teachings on significant matters reminiscent of homosexuality, women's ordination, or abortion, and are hence institutionally marginalized, decide to stay Catholic? Why do they remain, while the price of staying and being stigmatized would appear to be more than the advantages they may achieve from switching to non secular teams whose doctrines could validate their ideals on those matters? Michele Dillon, drawing upon in-depth interviews with Catholics who're overtly homosexual or lesbian, advocates of women's ordination, and pro-choice, investigates why and the way pro-change Catholics proceed to stay actively concerned with the Church, regardless of their rejection of the Vatican's instructing on sexuality and gender.
Read Online or Download Catholic Identity: Balancing Reason, Faith, and Power PDF
Similar catholicism books
The letters of St. Basil, 300 and sixty-eight in quantity, which contain the main vibrant and such a lot own component of his works, provide us, might be, the clearest perception into the wealth of his wealthy and sundry genius. They have been written in the years from 357, almost immediately prior to his retreat to the Pontus, till his dying in 378, a interval of significant unrest and persecution of the orthodox Catholic Church within the East.
Jordan Aumann, O. P. the well known writer supplies a whole evaluate and heritage of Catholic spirituality from the Apostles to the current day.
Lifestyles at the farm is peaceable and lucrative despite difficulties that crop up. by surprise disease and dying strike the kinfolk. Blaming herself, Miriam reveals it approximately most unlikely to deal with grief.
Extra resources for Catholic Identity: Balancing Reason, Faith, and Power
1 The church hierar1. , the Enlightenment) but to the circumstances and traditions of the communities (the laity) that comprise the church. The history of the Catholic Church contains many diverse strands that contribute to its mult if ace ted identity. This chapter draws on historical accounts of the church to highlight the origins of official teaching on the substantive issues of concern to this study's pro-change Catholics, namely homosexuality, the priesthood, and abortion. It does not provide an exhaustive historical analysis of the development of official church teaching on the specific doctrinal questions.
The canon law decrees compiled (between 1139 and 1150) by the twelfthcentury monk and legal scholar Gratian, restricted ensoulment to the formed fetus and categorized such abortions as homicides (ibid. 90-91). This teaching was given official recognition during the papacy of Innocent III (1198-1216) (ibid. 96-97).
I present data showing attitudinal differences among Dignity, WOC, and CFFC respondents on issues of faith, morality, sexuality, gender, and politics. I also introduce survey data from doctrinally conservative Catholics, respondents from the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights. These data underscore major differences between pro-change and conservative Catholics over interpretive authority and doctrine. Yet, of particular significance, the comparative analyses also point to several commonalities between the two doctrinally opposed groups.
Catholic Identity: Balancing Reason, Faith, and Power by Michele Dillon