By Richard Phelps, Herbert Walberg, J. E. Stone
Kill the Messenger may be the main thorough and authoritative paintings in safety of academic trying out ever written. Phelps issues out that a lot study performed by way of schooling insiders at the subject relies on ideological choice or profound self-interest. it isn't excellent that they come at emphatically anti-testing conclusions. a lot, if no longer such a lot, of this adverse study is handed directly to the general public by means of reporters as though it have been impartial, goal, and self sufficient. This quantity explains and refutes some of the universal criticisms of checking out; describes trying out competitors recommendations, via case reports of Texas and the SAT; illustrates the profound media bias opposed to trying out; recognizes testings barriers, and indicates the way it might be more desirable; and at last, outlines the implications of wasting the conflict on standardized trying out.
Read or Download Kill the messenger: the war on standardized testing PDF
Similar assessment books
This ebook makes a speciality of dilemmas inherent within the perform of overview within the modern context. New varieties of review are being brought in all sectors of schooling and coaching, and the tradition of evaluate is transferring. The authors during this quantity speak about the perform of evaluation, reporting empirical study on modes of review inside of numerous academic contexts, whereas additionally addressing conceptual and theoretical points of overview.
The Sage guide of analysis on school room evaluate offers students, professors, graduate scholars, and different researchers and coverage makers within the agencies, firms, trying out businesses, and faculty districts with a entire resource of analysis on all points of K-12 school room review. The guide emphasizes idea, conceptual frameworks, and all types of study (quantitative, qualitative, combined equipment) to supply an in-depth figuring out of the information base in every one zone of school room review and the way to behavior inquiry within the region.
Additional resources for Kill the messenger: the war on standardized testing
Now, some school administrators are being held accountable for improving student achievement; they regard the accountability measures to be imperfect and unfair, and they’re understandably feeling some pressure. Welcome, school administrators, to the world in which the rest of us live. Surely, there are circumstances where the pressure on school administrators might be unfair or test administration could be handled better. Unlike in most of the rest of the world’s education systems, high-stakes standardized tests are fairly new in the United States.
4. Expert Defenders. Yes, there is objective research conducted on testing. Indeed, there’s plenty. The objective research on testing tends to be conducted by academics outside of education schools (such as in psychology, sociology, or economics departments), by testing and measurement professors in education schools who may be shunned or ignored by their profession’s leadership, and by thousands who work inside test development firms. Many of these researchers believe that the benefits of tests vastly outweigh their drawbacks and so should be used.
4. State “minimum competency” examinations, which surfaced in many states starting in the 1970s, and whose passage was required for graduation from high school, did arouse some controversy. But, the exams were generally set at a very low level of difficulty (even as low as 6th grade), students were given many chances to pass in untimed conditions and, so, few failed. 5.
Kill the messenger: the war on standardized testing by Richard Phelps, Herbert Walberg, J. E. Stone